Sunday, September 9, 2012

Week 3, post 3


The concept/idea that I am going to talk about is the difference between punishing and disciplining a child. There are many definitions of punishment and discipline, and many people think they are pretty much the same thing. I believe that discipline is something that is done for you, not to you. Discipline is something that every child needs sometime throughout their lifetime in order to learn how to act in society. Discipline is much more of a positive influence than punishment. Discipline can be something like loss of playtime, taking toys away, and some occasional time outs. For example, when I was a young child I remember my behavior was out of line and as an act of discipline my mother did not let me go to baseball practice and instead I was on time out. At the time I was very angry and upset but in the end I think it helped me out. Once I cooled down my mother explained to me what I had done and that I cannot do that kind of thing in public. That is an example of a parent trying to discipline their child and trying to turn it into a positive experience. Punishment has to do more with physical and mental abuse. The example of what my mom did was not punishment because she wasn’t physically or mentally abusing me, she was trying to discipline me by doing something that what help me out in the long run.  

1 comment:

  1. I was agreeing with you on this post until you mentioned the idea that discipline is “the loss of playtime, taking toys away, and some occasional time-outs.” As far as I am concerned, these are all punishments. While the may be teaching you a lesson, you are still being punished for one reason or another. I believe that the distinction between punishment and discipline is that in discipline, there is a “method to the madness” if you will. In discipline, you are using effective techniques to teach a child the idea of actions versus consequences. Often times, this is done by enforcing a punishment. Now, if we’re talking about arbitrary punishment for no reason, this could potentially be classified as abuse. However, if were just talking about the semantics of a definition, I have to disagree with your classification of punishment/discipline as I think often times, they go hand-in-hand.

    ReplyDelete